Date of Award
Spring 4-30-2026
Author's Department
Graduate School of Art
Degree Name
Master of Fine Arts (MFA) in Illustration & Visual Culture
Degree Type
Thesis
Abstract
This essay argues that Undertale shifts the evaluative unit of play from isolated choice to repeated conduct. Rather than judging single decisions in the manner of overt morality systems, the game tracks how a player moves through its world across time: whether encounters are treated as obstacles to clear, situations to read, opportunities to dominate, or relations worth sustaining. It begins by borrowing the familiar grammar of the role-playing game, where combat yields experience, levels mark growth, and efficient violence appears synonymous with progress. In doing so, it activates habits many players have inherited from the genre before gradually exposing what those habits produce.
Through its neutral, pacifist, and genocide routes, Undertale reinterprets optimization, completionism, and replay as ethical orientations rather than neutral play styles. Procedural success can yield narratively thin outcomes; patience and attention open richer forms of relation; exhaustive mastery empties the world it seeks to complete. The figure of Flowey extends this logic, embodying the exhaustion produced by total familiarity, endless repetition, and consequence-free temporal revision.
The essay also examines how saving, loading, and resetting redistribute power between player and character. While most inhabitants of the Underground remain bound to a single present, the player carries memory across multiple versions of events, creating an asymmetry of knowledge and consequence central to the game’s moral force. In conversation with game studies and philosophy, I argue that Undertale rejects criticism that treats mechanics, narrative, and ethics as separable layers. Its meaning emerges instead through repetition, revision, impatience, restraint, and the habits that play makes possible.
Language
English
Program Chair
John Hendrix
Recommended Citation
Favaloro, Isabel R., "Kill or Be Killed: A Reading of Conduct and Consequence" (2026). MFA in Illustration & Visual Culture. 60.
https://repository.library.washu.edu/mfa_illustration/60